Caravaggio and the Painters of the North
From 21 June to 18 September 2016
In addition to painting scenes of street life with picturesque characters inspired by his years in Rome, Sweerts also produced a few portraits as well as a series of half-length and bust-length elderly and young men and boys. These figures are depicted against a plain, dark background with the head turned to one side and the light entering from the left. Among the finest examples is Boy in a Hat in the Wadsworth Atheneum, Hartford.
The present canvas does not form part of that series but the treatment of the light and modelling derives from the artist’s experience in Italy. The canvas was first published and made known to the wider public when it was included in the exhibition entitled Artists in Seventeenth-century Rome held in London in 1955. At that point it was catalogued as a work by Sweerts and has been considered one of his most attractive works since that date. It was previously attributed to Francesco de Rosa, according to a label on the reverse.
In the 20th century the painting first reappeared in Rome in 1955 in the collection of Andrea Burisi Vici, and Gaskell has suggested that it may have been in the Barberini collection, a proposal based on the style of the frame, which is typical of that collection, and the remains of an old inventory label on the reverse. However, Gaskell was unable to associate the painting with any work in 17th-century inventories of that collection. After it was auctioned in London and passed through two private collections it was acquired for the Thyssen-Bornemisza collection in 1981.
Boy in a Turban holding a Nosegay has been associated with the group of paintings that Sweerts executed at the end of his Amsterdam period. The subject of the present painting and the sex of the figure have been the focus of debate and have given rise to different interpretations. The gentle, delicate features and the turban hiding the hair make it difficult to define the subject precisely, and the canvas was previously entitled Figure in a Turban. It was only in 1958, when the painting was included in an exhibition on Sweerts in Rotterdam, that the sitter was described as a boy, a reading that has been maintained in the present day.
The fact that the boy is holding a nosegay has led to the suggestion that this is a representation of the sense of Smell. Sweerts executed two, now dispersed, series on the Five Senses. In one series, which uses a similar format to the present painting, five male figures in exotic dress hold objects and animals related to the senses. In the second series, which is smaller and now incomplete, young boys symbolise the senses through a snuffed-out candle, a musical score and a finger bandaged to protect a small wound. No other work by Sweerts or attributed to him can be associated with the present canvas and thus indicate the existence of a third series. However, objects such as flowers, sweet-smelling vegetables and other scented materials were traditionally used in art to evoke the sense of smell. On the other hand, it has been suggested that the nosegay is simply a decorative element in the painting.
Mahon and Sutton dated the canvas to the end of the painter’s time in Italy, around 1654. However, Gaskell and Kultzen disagreed, and the latter dated it to the end of the 1650s, including it among Sweerts’ portraits although considering that it might have an allegorical meaning.
The image of this boy is conveyed with a great sense of volume through the modelling and the combination of colours chosen for the clothes. The large area of blue cloak, painted in a highly linear manner with regard to the application of the pigment and the construction of the folds, is contrasted with the pale yellow of the turban, the immaculate white of the shirt and the red of some of the flowers and the sash. The brilliant depiction of the turban and the skilled pose and modelling of the figure make this one of Sweerts’ most successful paintings.